Yue opera has captivated audiences with its all-female productions since the 1930s, touching hearts with countless tales of love and relationships. In an interview with FestMag, the director of the Shanghai Yue Opera House, Fang Yafen, reveals how Yue opera's themes of pursuing love and independence resonate with female audiences, offering an emotional outlet.
The Shanghai Yue Opera House will present several classic Yue opera works and excerpts at the 2025 Hong Kong Arts Festival. Fang Yafen will play Zhu Yingtai in The Butterfly Lovers (Yuan & Fan Version), portraying Zhu as spirited and intelligent in female attire, and as bold and heroic when disguised as a man. Liang Shanbo, played by Zhang Ruihong, differs from traditional male protagonists, as he is not only handsome but also tender. In the renowned "Reunion on the Terrace", after their long-awaited reunion following "Shanbo Accompanies Yingtai on a Homeward Journey", Liang's joy turns to sorrow and anger upon learning that Zhu has been betrothed to another man. Fang explains that this role, which resonates with popular sentiment, presents a great challenge: "The difficulty lies in breaking through established styles while maintaining my own unique interpretation, bringing forth a performance full of raw emotion. It's just physically and mentally exhausting."
The Yuan & Fan Version of The Butterfly Lovers originated from a 1954 colour Yue opera film starring Yuan Xuefen and Fan Ruijuan. Yuan Xuefen, a founding member of the Shanghai Yue Opera House and Fang Yafen's mentor, never performed this play on stage after the release of the film, keeping it out of theatres for more than 60 years. In 2012, to commemorate the first anniversary of her teacher's passing, Fang restaged the production, bringing back one of Yuan's three most iconic crying scenes, "Yingtai Mourns at the Tomb", stirring poignant emotions among the audience. As Fang had never seen Yuan perform this piece on stage, she could only refer to Yuan's acting in the film version. Combining this with her own strengths, she made every effort to preserve Yuan's vocal style while integrating elements like the original film music.
Fang explains that Yue opera, originally known as Shaoxing opera, developed its unique language by incorporating the Zhongzhou dialect and ancient Mandarin phonetics into its Shengzhou dialect. Yue opera has a history of just more than 110 years. Initially performed by all-male troupes, women were prohibited from participating until the 1930s and 40s when all-female Yue opera started to emerge.
"In the 1930s, the introduction of female performers, especially actresses playing male roles, satisfied the desire for women to create idealised male characters— dashingly charming, respectful of women, gentle and considerate—a projection of women's emotional aspirations," says Fang. She points to the male protagonists of the excerpts "Reunion at the Garden", from Questioning His Wife and Demanding to Find His Wife, and "Fortune-telling", from He Wenxiu, as perfect examples of the "sweet, caring guy" image.
Fang believes that Yue opera's appeal to women lies in stories that allow female characters to pursue love freely. In The Butterfly Lovers, for example, the plot is emotionally rich with bold expressions of love. "In areas like autonomy in marriage, mutual respect and reciprocal love, women were historically repressed. Through the emotions in the opera, they found an outlet for their feelings. It used to be said that you couldn't watch Yue opera without bringing a handkerchief to wipe away tears." She cites The Jade Hairpin as an example: "The heroine, Li Xiuying, is mistreated by her husband, and while the social constraints of the time prevent her from rebelling, she ultimately compels him to kneel and apologise in the scene 'Presenting the Phoenix Headdress'. For women, this provides a sense of satisfaction after releasing their grievances."
However, Yue opera is not only about the tender romances of ordinary women, but also encompasses themes of loyalty and national duty. In "Farewell at Chongtai", from The Soul of the Plum Blossom, the heroine Chen Xingyuan is married off to a foreign prince to secure peace for the kingdom, even though it means leaving her true love behind. "These female characters may appear delicate, but they carry immense inner strength."
In the 1950s, Yuan spearheaded reforms in Yue opera, expanding its repertoire and music, and enhancing its production scale, eventually raising its international profile. Over time, the troupe began admitting male actors, and since 1959 it has been performing both all-female and mixed-gender productions, making this a unique feature of the troupe. This approach maintains a balance between modern sensibilities and traditional characteristics, though male Yue opera actors remain relatively rare.
Now the troupe is bringing a range of performances to Hong Kong that showcase both all-female and mixed-gender productions. Among them is Family, adapted from Ba Jin's novel of the same name, which features a male and female cast, with Zhao Zhigang, known as the "Prince of Yue Opera", in the lead role. The production is filled with rich tales of love and family. "While different schools and styles are important tools, what truly touches the audience is the emotional expression of the performers—it has to reach deep into the heart. Whether it's a mixed-gender or an all-female production, Yue opera always stands out because of the way we convey emotions through the story," Fang concludes.
Shanghai Yue Opera House
Date: 27 Feb – 1 Mar 2025
Venue: Grand Theatre, Hong Kong Cultural Centre